The federal judge overseeing a criminal tax shelter case indicated Monday that he might not dismiss charges after all against a dozen indicted defendants from KPMG, The New York Times reported.
In a significant shift, Judge Lewis A. Kaplan, of Federal District Court in Manhattan, indicated that he would reconsider a landmark ruling he made last year in which he raised the possibility of dismissing all or part of the high-profile case on the ground of prosecutorial misconduct, the paper reported.
In that closely watched ruling, known as Stein I, Kaplan said that federal prosecutors had violated the rights of certain KPMG defendants by pressuring KPMG not to pay their legal fees as a condition of not indicting the firm over its own tax shelter work. For that reason, he wrote in the ruling, he might have to throw the case out, the paper reported.
But Kaplan changed course Monday, telling a packed courtroom that “the ground has shifted” regarding the question of dismissal. He added later that “I see a very clear distinction between violation and remedy” — indicating, for the first time, that he was now open to finding a way to resolve the legal fees issue without dismissing the case, the paper reported.
According to the paper, on the question of dismissal, he later told the courtroom, “I don’t know where I am.”-New York State Society of Certified Public Accountants